Why Does a Magnet Fall Slowly Through Copper?

Why does a magnet fall slowly through copper when it drops quickly through plastic? In a copper pipe, the moving magnet sets electric charges in motion. The resulting currents produce their own magnetic fields, and the force from those fields acts upward on the falling magnet. The copper does not have to attract the magnet the way an iron object does. The braking comes from motion, not from the magnet sticking to the pipe.
Why does a magnet fall slowly through copper but not plastic?
Stand two pipes upright, one copper and one plastic, with similar lengths and inside diameters. Use the same cylindrical magnet for both drops. Choose one that can pass through either pipe without scraping the wall, and release it from rest at the same height relative to each opening. Put a soft catch tray beneath the pipes and compare the time from release to landing. In a clear demonstration, the magnet takes noticeably longer to come out of the copper pipe.
Both pipes hide the magnet while it falls, but only the copper pipe produces substantial electromagnetic braking. Copper conducts electricity well, so charges can move through its walls. Ordinary plastic is an electrical insulator, so it does not support sizable circulating currents in this experiment. If the pipes are wide enough to let air pass freely around the magnet and the magnet does not rub the walls, the drop through plastic is close to an ordinary free fall.
The moving magnet changes the flux
Imagine drawing a circle around the copper pipe at one height. That circle marks a possible path for current. It encloses a disk across the pipe opening. Magnetic flux measures how much magnetic field passes through that disk, taking into account the strength and direction of the field across the area. The disk is imaginary. The copper around its edge is real, and it provides a conducting path all the way around.
As the magnet approaches the circle, passes through it, and moves away, the flux through the disk changes. Faraday's law says that changing magnetic flux induces a voltage around a loop. In the copper, that voltage drives a current. There is no battery, and the magnet does not need to touch the wall. The pipe is one continuous piece of metal, so the currents are spread through the wall rather than confined to separate wire loops. These circulating currents are called eddy currents.
A stationary magnet can produce a magnetic field through the same disk without driving a lasting current. If the magnet and the pipe are held still relative to one another, the flux stops changing, and any currents left over from earlier motion die away because copper has electrical resistance. For a textbook treatment of the distinction between flux and changing flux, see OpenStax's explanation of Faraday's law.
Copper below pushes and copper above pulls
Lenz's law gives the direction of each induced current: the field it creates opposes the change in flux that produced it. The word change matters. The current's field does not always point against the magnet's field. When the flux is decreasing, the induced field acts to sustain it instead.
Picture the magnet falling with its north pole pointing down. A ring of copper ahead of it, below the magnet, experiences increasing flux as the north pole comes closer. The induced current makes the ring act like a magnet with a north pole on the side facing the approaching north pole. The two repel. Because the ring is below the falling magnet, that repulsion pushes the magnet upward.
Now picture a ring above the magnet. The magnet's south pole is moving away from that ring, so the flux there is decreasing. The induced current makes the side of the ring facing the magnet act like a north pole. That side attracts the retreating south pole. Since this ring is above the magnet, its pull is upward too. The current below and the current above circulate in opposite directions when viewed from the same end of the pipe, but both contribute to braking. Flip the magnet over and the current directions reverse; the braking force is still upward.
Gravity keeps doing work
The magnet does not lose weight in the pipe. Gravity still pulls down while the induced currents produce an upward force. Over a suitable range of speeds, faster motion changes the flux more rapidly, driving stronger currents and increasing the braking force. In a long enough uniform pipe, the magnet can reach a nearly steady speed where the upward force balances its weight. With almost no net force, it keeps moving downward at almost constant speed. The guide to drawing a free-body diagram shows how to represent a balance like this without mistaking it for an absence of forces.
At steady speed, the magnet is not gaining kinetic energy, but it is still losing gravitational potential energy. The induced currents transfer energy to the copper, where electrical resistance converts it into heat. A single drop may not warm the pipe enough for you to notice. The energy transfer still takes place, just as it does when current warms a wire.
A slit tests the current path
A copper pipe with a narrow slit running its full length offers a second comparison. The slit interrupts paths that would otherwise carry current all the way around the pipe. Smaller current loops can still form in the metal, so the braking need not disappear. But in an otherwise comparable pipe, the magnet should fall faster than it does through the intact one. The pipe is still copper and the magnet still has the same field. What changed is where the current can flow.
For a written exercise alongside the IPhyC practice problems, sketch a magnet with its south pole pointing down and draw one copper ring above it and one below it. Label the face of each ring nearest the magnet as north or south, then mark the force each ring exerts on the magnet. Use the same viewing direction for both rings if you also draw the currents.
Frequently asked questions
Does the magnet have to touch the copper?
No. A changing magnetic field induces currents across the gap between the magnet and the pipe, so braking can happen without contact.
Will the magnet stop halfway down the pipe?
Not because of eddy current braking alone. If the magnet stopped, the flux would stop changing, the currents would decay, and gravity would pull it downward again.
Would an aluminum pipe also slow the magnet?
Yes. Aluminum conducts electricity and can support eddy currents, although the amount of braking depends on the pipe and the magnet.


